Today's Viewpoint: A MarshBerry Publication

The Case Against A V-shaped” Recovery”

Economic Recovery

All of us would like to hope for a rapid return to normalcy once the economy is reopened by the government. We keep hearing that economic activity will recover quickly (e.g. a “V-Shaped” recovery) as consumers return to a pre-crisis way of life. Society will unhesitatingly return to eating in restaurants, going to sporting events, even hugging strangers. This theory rests upon the assumption that people and businesses will act as if there is little to no danger of a “second wave” COVID-19 infection hitting the U.S. in late 2020 – early 2021.

But what if the population is more cautious in its return from isolation? With heightened awareness of social distancing, people choosing to buy local, and various work from home scenarios emerging, there likely will not be a return to the way it was but rather a reframing of a “new normal.” As an insurance distributor, how would you plan to operate your business differently if a new normal arises? What if people are still too scared to engage in more than very limited personal interactions with strangers? Over the next few days, MarshBerry will explore ways in which insurance brokers could consider planning for operating in a distorted economy (i.e. the New Normal) where economic recovery is much slower than some pundits have predicted (i.e. a “U-Shaped” recovery) and the reset is different than pre-pandemic way of life.

Before we explore how to make 2020 a successful year within the ”new normal,” we will make the case for why a U-Shaped recovery is feasible, perhaps even likely. This case begins with the hypothesis that the economy will not open all at once. More likely, the economy will open in stages, depending upon the level of infections and available hospital resources and capacity. It seems logical to conclude that, absent a major outbreak, that Omaha, NE will reopen much sooner than New York, NY. This rolling reintroduction of consumer and business spending, even if there is no trepidation on the part of consumers to reengage in close personal interaction, will delay an economic recovery.

Second, a V-Shaped recovery assumes that the vast majority of closed businesses will reopen (and do so quickly). We would argue that a more likely scenario suggests that many of these businesses will not reopen at all due to the economic hardship that they have suffered while shuttered. As an example, the South China Morning Post reported on April 6, 2020, that nearly 500,000 small businesses in China have gone bankrupt as a result of COVID-19. It is not impossible to assume that the U.S. could suffer a similar, though not as severe, result.

Third, the population may remain cautious about attending large public gatherings such as sporting events or rock concerts. Parts of the economy could reopen while still under a government proviso to wear masks, keep social distancing, and stay home if one is feeling ill. Such a reopening would have significant implications for the number of former employees who return to work. If restaurants are only serving at 40% capacity, do they only need 30% of their pre-crisis staff? What if sporting events are held for a TV audience, without fans in the stadium? There is no need for employees to take tickets, sell hot dogs or clean restrooms. In fact, on Fox’s Sunday News Hour with Chris Wallace, Dallas Maverick’s owner Mark Cuban suggested that the NBA season will be played with only a skeleton TV crew and scoreboard operators. The stands are likely to be empty.

Finally, what if many professional organizations decide that video conferencing is a great way to cut travel and entertainment costs? By the time the economy reopens, many professionals will be well versed in virtual meetings. Firms could use the crisis to permanently change the way they use technology to hold introductory “meetings.” If face-to-face meetings are supplanted with video conferencing, how many professional businesses are likely to rehire receptionists, especially with fewer onsite visitors? If business travel is permanently impacted by an increase in virtual meetings, why rehire an admin who spends a significant amount of their time making or changing travel arrangements?

It does not take a giant leap of faith to acknowledge that a return to normalcy (defined as our pre-crisis way of doing business) may not re-emerge in the near term, or perhaps for a very long time, if ever. A ”new normal” could easily develop instead.

Under such a U-Shaped recovery, the implications for insurance demand could be significant. For instance, delays in buying insurance coverage could result from a rolling opening of the economy. Worse still, total insurance exposures could be reduced across the economy if there are more permanent reductions in workforces, travel and liability exposures. In sum, MarshBerry suggests it is time to toss out the old five-year playbook and re-write the 2020 business plan.

The remainder of this week, we will concentrate upon how our clients may consider going about revising their business strategy in an increasingly uncertain and turbulent environment.

If you have questions about Today’s ViewPoint or would like to learn more about what recovery for insurance agents and brokers might look like, please email or call Gerard Vecchio, President – Senior Vice President at 212.972.4886.

Subscribe to MarshBerry’s Today’s ViewPoint blog for the latest news and updates and follow us on social media.

Investment banking services offered through MarshBerry Capital, Inc., Member FINRA Member SIPC and an affiliate of Marsh, Berry & Company, Inc. 28601 Chagrin Boulevard, Suite 400, Woodmere, Ohio 44122 (440.354.3230)

MarshBerry continues to be the #1 sell side advisor in the industry (as ranked by S&P Global). If you're considering selling your firm, we are the best choice to help you through the complicated process. If you don't hire MarshBerry, hire a reputable advisor that can help you navigate one of the most important business decisions you will ever make. You will be much better off having an advisor in your corner that knows the industry than trying to do this on your own.